|

Smoking Man and Buddha, Hangzhou China,
2002
shanghai
city of cranes
There are images and ideas of China that
I have only from visiting Shanghai, and then there are those things
that seemed immediately familiar to me when I arrived because I
had already read them in the online diaries of my friend Dan, whom
I visited there in the fall of 2002. What I wasn’t prepared
for was how completely those dispatches of everyday life epitomize
larger themes about Shanghai: the city’s mad flirtation with
capitalism, the back alleys of Chinese tradition that seem to have
survived ruthless development, the almost unseemly mix of Eastern
and Western culture. If that sounds violent and maybe a little seedy,
you’re getting an idea of the character of the city, of its
pace and its density. Even after living in New York for many years,
I was still unprepared for the cultural and economic extremes I
witnessed in the very short time I was there. I was surprised daily
by the sheer volume of people that Shanghai holds in its sprawling
arms. It is the only city I have ever been in, at home or abroad,
that rivals New York in its “city-ness” Shanghai moves
with a kind of severe flow, a churning that will either pull you
under or throw you into unexpected splendor.
Knowing my
time was limited, Dan tossed me in the waters immediately: within
two hours of my arrival, I had sped through the city in a taxi and
had Dan’s now famous “meat on a stick” handed
to me for dinner. Though these rough cuts of pork with cumin and
pepper might seem pedestrian, consider that Shanghai’s economics
and culture are turned over on the same spit. Depending on your
means and your tastes, you can eat traditional Chinese food in the
alley for a dollar a day, or have an eight-dollar scoop of Haagen-Dazs
as dessert. But unlike an international corporation equipped with
an army of accountants and marketing squads, Dan’s “meat
guy” competes with a bicycle outfitted with a small coal-fired
stove on the rack. It’s brilliantly engineered for a quick
get-away in the event the police come to roust him and the other
vendors from their precarious position as culinary squatters. They
are citizens of a tight encampment just outside the gates of Shanghai
University. You would expect that in a communist dictatorship, fewer
people would be willing to flout the local laws, but it seems de
rigueur for the natives to make a little cash however they can (and
a little more from you if you don’t know how to haggle). Their
entrepreneurship is almost like guerilla warfare, and full-fledged
economic freedom will no doubt level the city once again, pulling
it back into the rubble of its most recent boom.
The once demure
Shanghai is now a regular bedfellow of the cultural change and rapid
commerce that accompany contemporary foreign influence. After its
humble beginnings as a fishing village, just a simple country girl,
it rebuffed trade with European countries for centuries —
while battling Japanese and Portuguese pirates — finally succumbing
to a British invasion in 1842. The English and their colonial spirit
weren’t interested this time in a wholesale land-grab, but
in a no less disruptive commercial coupling: the incursion led to
the Treaty of Nanking, and on December 14, 1843, Shanghai officially
— reluctantly — opened for business with the West. The
Opium Wars further Westernized the city, the Cultural Revolution
“reclaimed” it and now Shanghai is again actively cultivating
its reputation as a worldly participant in the international community.
While I was
there, it was announced that the next World Expo would be held in
Shanghai, the appropriately monikered City of Cranes. Blue cranes
flying into the sky on delicate Chinese porcelain represent a rise
in status, and Shanghai’s ubiquitous construction cranes are
no less symbolic. It is not an exaggeration to say that everywhere
— everywhere — there is bamboo scaffolding costuming
the city in the clothes of Western architecture and contemporary
influence. Newspaper coverage of the imminent Expo was complete
with pictures of crying government officials, crying with joy that
Shanghai had been cast to appear in the world’s spotlight.
Exit the blue cranes and enter the blueprints: shortly after wiping
away their tears, those same officials were finalizing plans that
will demolish old neighborhoods and old buildings in order to accommodate
the temporary influx of the international community, and to ensure
that when visitors arrive in Shanghai, there are, for instance,
at least 100 different museums to greet them. That many Starbucks
might be in business right now, assuring us that the world’s
next brief affair with the Pearl of the Orient will be properly
caffeinated. Light up a Double Happiness cigarette, and the transaction
will be complete.
I visited several
existing museums while I was there, including the Chinese Sex Museum,
where even amid the ancient stone dildos you could hear the hammers
and saws of construction. In the beautiful and much more traditional
Shanghai Art Museum in People’s Square, a display of precious
calligraphy manuscripts was attracting visitors from around the
globe. In the New Shanghai Art Museum, only blocks away but devoid
of a single Japanese tour group, Chinese students had mounted a
contemporary art exhibit that was thematically arranged around the
city’s unstoppable development. All of the pieces addressed
this latest incarnation of Shanghai, and many of them suggested,
in a less-than-subtle manner, that not everyone is pleased with
it. Not least of which those people who will be displaced from the
neighborhoods they now live in to accommodate the Expo, yet another
point of contention among the locals.
According to
Dan’s friend Johnson, even native Shanghainese find themselves
getting lost because their own city is sometimes unrecognizable
to them. It reminded me very much of the futuristic noir film Dark
City, in which a race of aliens uses their combined mental power
each night to completely change the landscape of an experimental
dystopia — and to significantly alter the lives and memories
of each person who lives there. In an attempt to save themselves
from dying out as their own natural environment withers, they vainly
seek to realize how it is we can survive such radical change. Shanghai,
and the people who live there, seem to be undergoing the same sort
of experiment as they struggle to retain their character and culture
in the face of this latest round of considerable foreign influence.
Laundy at the Market,
Shanghi, China 2002
Despite the
radical changes going on, Shanghai is still, of course, a Chinese
city. Jellyfish is supposed to taste good, everyone rides a bike,
and big brother is watching. Even Dan’s neighborhood, gentrifying
as you read this, is still under significantly less Western influence
than Shanghai’s downtown. After a few hours of sleep the first
night I came in, I woke up early and made my way down to the farmer’s
market, one of the highlights of my trip — a place that you
would never find among the sterile streets of Pudong and its Jetsons-esque
skyline. It’s full of health practices that would make most
Westerners squirm, but it was crammed with locals who were eager
to buy everything from simple fruits and vegetables to a stunning
array of turtles, crayfish, eels and recently slaughtered ducks
— or live ducks, if they preferred. I was greeted here with
many an enthusiastic “Hello!” and just as many surprised
looks when I answered with a Chinese greeting of “Ni Hao!”
Some people
shied away from my cameras (I carried two the entire time I was
there, like some reporter without an assignment) others laughed
and smiled and tried to get me to take pictures of their co-workers
or their children. One 2-year old boy, after realizing that his
mother had sold him out — she diverted him by getting his
attention while I snapped several photos — threw his arms
in front of his face when he saw the camera, as if I were a sun
that was burning his eyes. I also endured many quizzical looks from
people who were obviously baffled by why I needed to take close-ups
of vegetables. Tourists they understand, but not fetishists of produce.
I suppose I don’t blame them. It is pretty strange to be psyched
about a particularly good-looking bunch of carrots. I guess that’s
my own character exerting itself.
Even closer
to Dan’s dorm, every morning there were many older people
out walking and exercising. Some walk backwards as they pat themselves.
Others stand with bent knees and briskly bob several inches up and
down. Still others do Tai Chi on their own. The most novel exercise
group consisted of some chatty women circled around a tree. One
had thrown her leg up in the low crook, another held her hands high
to hold the trunk above, and two women on either side were patting
down separate branches. It’s an exercise regime that I don’t
believe will be offered soon in American gyms, even in trendier
establishments alongside spinning classes and Pilates. There were
many times I wish that I spoke just a little Chinese so that I could
have asked a question, but never more so than the morning with the
tree huggers. They seemed like they were my people.

Sleeping Monk at the Temple Entrance,
Island of Putuoshan, China
Still further
away from the steamroller of Westernization was the beautiful island
of Putuoshan. Here the only churning was the quiet pull of the slow
boat’s engine along the ocean — a twelve-hour overnight
ferry ride, which was a three-hour ride on the “fast boat”
home. Like Taipei, this island virtually escaped the Cultural Revolution
and its main attraction is its many working Buddhist temples. (And
unlike Hangzhou, where we also visited a temple, Putuoshan doesn’t
feel as though it was pre-packaged for tourists — no Pizza
Hut here.) Putuoshan is, as the guidebooks tell you, the romanticized
version of China that you hope for: pagodas, chanting, incense and
an atmosphere that cultivates inner peace. Here, instead of taking
taxis to get to our next destination, we walked for miles along
beautiful roads, hiked up trails lined with trees and ocean vistas
and descended stone staircases that led to temples perched on the
East China Sea. The monks may occasionally use cell phones, but
most of their calls are to Buddha, for peace and clarity of mind.
Though the incense eventually burned my lungs and made my first
night’s musical performance back in Shanghai an adventure
in itself (thanks again to Geding for being my roadie and to Bliss
for her beautiful violin accompaniment), it was worth it to have
been in such an amazing place.
Not that Shanghai is any less stunning in its own way. I know that
it’s unique among Chinese cities, and spending just two weeks
there has made me extremely interested in seeing other cultures
and regions within China. But just as the sheltered island of Putuoshan
seemed timeless, somehow serving to illustrate the Buddhist principal
that everything is one, Shanghai bares out the principle given to
us by Heraclitus: you never step into the same river twice. It won’t
be the same place it was when I was there if I’m able to see
it again when I return — if it continues to churn and flow
out into the sea along with the Huangpu, my next trip to China might
be my first trip to China.
©2004-2005
Little red records |